Appel à communications: 4th Interdisciplinary Market Studies Workshop (8-10 juin 2016)
4th Interdisciplinary Market Studies Workshop
June 8-10, 2016
School of Management, University of St Andrews
(Im)Possible markets: Putting market studies to work
Since its first meeting in 2010, the Interdisciplinary Market Studies Workshop has established a thriving community of scholars with a shared interest in the conception, construction, organisation and operation of markets. Participants have presented detailed empirical accounts of market formation and change processes, mundane market practices, performativity, worth and valuation, and have discussed the power of markets alongside ideas of creativity and personhood.
In approaching such topics, market studies has drawn heavily on ideas from neighbouring disciplines, and there has been travel in the reverse direction too: market studies has surfaced in marketing (Araujo, Finch, & Kjellberg, 2010), organization studies (McFall & Ossandon, 2014; Roscoe & Chillas, 2014) and science and technology studies (MacKenzie, 2006; Doganova & Karnoe, 2015). But there is still much potential for productive exchange with cognate disciplines, particularly (economic) sociology, anthropology, consumption studies, management and organisation studies. Given the politically charged nature of markets under neoliberalism, market studies is also poised for productive dialogue with political science and political economy.
This 4th workshop aims to strengthen links with other disciplines and further develop market studies as an interdisciplinary field. In asking what the performative, civilising or disciplining consequences of market organisation might be, it seeks to reposition long-standing research questions around the politics and ethics of markets with a focus on the performativity and power of market arrangements. We ask what markets do, and why they matter. We seek to invigorate market studies by encouraging studies of markets and quasi-markets (systems of organization based on exchange, barter and allocation) that are powerful, yet questionable; markets for market alien goods (Fourcade, 2011); markets on the edge of society (Pettinger, 2012), or technology (Roscoe, 2015); markets with the possibility for resistance and rejuvenation (Maurer, 2003). What are the narratives that accompany alternative market forms – novel currencies (Maurer, Nelms, & Swartz, 2013), ‘fairtrade’ (Dolan, 2010) or ‘bottom of the pyramid’ (Dolan, 2013), the ‘sharing economy’, crowdfunding, or renting – and how do actually existing markets operationalise such ideas?
This also presents a critical challenge –what might the emancipatory possibilities of market studies be? What does the performative stance associated with much work in market studies mean for critical scholarship – is ‘critical performativity’ even possible? (Spicer, Alvesson, & Karreman, 2009; Tadajewski, 2010). What are the politics of markets and of market models? How are markets incorporated into systems of redistribution, ‘development’ and ‘empowerment’? (Blowfield and Dolan, 2014). What orders of worth do they represent? Submissions might explore how local forms of worth and ethics are entangled in market arrangements; the processes (performative or otherwise) by which market models are brought into being and made thinkable; or the processes and practices through which market models, despite failure, are sustained and reproduced. How does market design interact with the construction of the institutions and procedures of contemporary political democracy?
Finally, how would we do it differently? How might we intervene in the design of the
architecture of markets (Fligstein, 2001)? What can market studies say about economic
engineering (Roth, 2002) or ‘nudge’ theory, fast becoming the guiding theories for contemporary policy? What should we say about algorithmic markets? Following recent innovative contributions to our field, we ask contributors to imagine the possibility for
bricolage and ‘hacking’ of market arrangements, to ask if markets can solve problems and to explore the mundane and the everyday, alongside the powerful and the political. We welcome innovative approaches, conceptual work, and blue-sky thinking – markets possible and impossible – as well as empirical accounts of actually existing market arrangements. In the end we hope to ask, with MacKenzie (2006), what kind of a (market) world might we wish to see performed.
Speakers: We are delighted to welcome Professor Donald MacKenzie and Dr Catherine
Dolan as keynote speakers for the workshop. Donald MacKenzie is professor of sociology at Edinburgh University and has for many years been one of the pre-eminent researchers of markets; a founder of ‘social studies of finance’, he is particularly known for his studies of financial derivatives and high-speed trading. Catherine Dolan is reader in anthropology at SOAS, and is interested in the cultural and political economy of markets and development. Her current research centres on the corporation as an agent of development and explores how business engages development concerns under the aegis of ‘responsible capitalism’.
Venue: The workshop will be held at the School of Management of the University of St
Andrews, from the evening of 8 June to mid-afternoon 10 June, 2016. St Andrews is a scenic town on the Fife coast, famous for its ancient university and its golf courses. It is easily accessible by road, rail, and with regular connections to Edinburgh airport. For more details, see http://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/about/visiting/travel/. Accommodation will be in the university’s Agnes Blackadder Hall, approximately five minutes’ walk from the School of Management.
How to submit: We invite contributors to submit a one to three page abstract/paper proposal to firstname.lastname@example.org. Proposals should indicate topic, theoretical positioning, methodology and outline findings, if appropriate. The deadline for submissions is Sunday, January 31, 2016. Inquiries about the workshop can be made to any of the workshop organisers. We will notify contributors about acceptance by early March, and full papers will be due early May.
Kimberly Chong, University College London, email@example.com
Hans Kjellberg, Stockholm School of Economics, firstname.lastname@example.org
Alexandre Mallard, Ecole des Mines ParisTech, email@example.com
Philip Roscoe, University of St Andrews, firstname.lastname@example.org